Thursday, November 3, 2022

Manslaughter By Mortician

 

Yesterday I shared one of my previous blogs on a Facebook group entitled “Kentucky Mountains- Old Photos and Stories.”   And in the comments on my post, George Johnson asked me if I had heard about the murder of his Great Uncle Thurman Johnson at the hands of a Greenup County undertaker / coroner.  I had not heard of the case. But I was immediately interested in the case for a few reasons: 1) it’s a historic crime and 2) I just happen to be a licensed funeral director and embalmer in the state of Kentucky myself.  3) You just don’t hear of undertakers / morticians (both archaic terms, by the way) committing murder.    So I immediately went to work researching this case.

Thurman Johnson, courtesy 
of Family Search

Thurman Johnson came to Flatwoods, Ky., near Russell, from West Virginia in 1925 and worked in the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad shops at Russell. Before coming to Kentucky, he had lost one arm when working in a West Virginia coal mine. In 1933, Johnson purchased the farm six miles southwest of Greenup. 

 L.G. Stapf was a wealthy Greenup County undertaker who owned part of the Stapf and Mitchell Funeral Home in Greenup.
L.G. Stapf - courtesy of
The Greenup Bacon



The story begins on March 26, 1944.  In a report by the Cincinnati Enquirer (March 28, 1944), Greenup Deputy Sheriff William Adkins stated that one of Stapf’s brood sows invaded Johnson’s property. Johnson shot the sow.  Stapf’s son, Renauld, who was operating the farm, along with 16 year old farm worker Ralph Bates, ran into Greenup and told his father that Johnson had killed the sow.

The elder Stapf went to Johnson’s farm to discuss the matter.  And they were close to reaching an amicable agreement over the damage to Johnson’s grass, when Johnson began cursing Renaurd.  When L.G. Stapf stepped in to defend his son, Johnson attacked Stapf with a knife, prompting Stapf to shoot Johnson three times.

   Two of the bullets had punctured Johnson’s liver and one penetrated one arm, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer (March 27 and March 28, 1944).

Johnson’s wife drove him to the King’s Daughters’ Hospital in Ashland where Dr. C.B. Johnson of Russell, KY performed surgery on the victim.

Soon after the shooting, Stapf went to Greenup, placed his $500.00 bond with Greenup County Sheriff Earl McKenzie, and employed the services of Attorney John F. Coldiron to represent him.  Stapf was initially charged with shooting with intent to kill. 

The next day, according to the Lexington Herald-Leader (March 27, 1944), Stapf’s bond was increased to $1,500.00 after Judge G.W. Burchett learned that the condition of Johnson had become critical.  Stapf paid the additional $1,000.00.

On March 28, 1944, Johnson passed away from his injuries. And Stapf’s charges were upgraded to  murder.  Stapf claimed self-defense in the shooting. His bond was again increased, this time to $5,000, which he immediately paid.   Stapf waived the examining trial and the charge was to be considered by the May 1944  Greenup grand jury. Renaurd Stapf was charged with aiding and abetting.

On May 3, 1944, L.G. Stapf was indicted for the murder of Thurman Johnson.   He provided the $6,000 bond and his trial was scheduled for May 16 by Judge Harvey Parker. Stapf retained three attorneys to represent him: John Coldiron, T.E. Nickel, and J.D. Atkinson.   Thurman Johnson’s widow, Jane, retained A.W. Mann to assist County Attorney Roy Wilhoit in the prosecution. (Source: Cincinnati Enquirer, May 4, 1944)

Allegedly, Stapf had had a heart ailment for three years prior to the shooting.  So the week of the trial, his attorneys had filed affidavits from Dr. H.H. Holbrook of Greenup, Dr. W. F. Marting of Ironton, Ohio, and Dr. E.C. McGhee of Ashland stating that Stapf had a heart condition.  His attorneys stated that because of that, he would be unable to attend the trial.

Acting on a petition filed by Roy Wilhoit, Commonwealth Attorney, Judge Parker appointed Dr. S.C. Smith and Dr. James Scott to examine Stapf to determine if he was in fact physically able to stand trial. (Source: Cincinnati Enquirer May 17, 1944).

The Louisville Courier- Journal reported on May 21, 1944 that the state appointed physicians found Stapf unable to stand trial at that time, and therefore the trial date was set for July 5, 1944.

Two panels of prospective jurors totaling 74 people were exhausted in the jury selection. Only 11 jurors were chosen from that group. More than half were objected because they opposed the death penalty.  This prompted Judge Parker to issue a call for 20 more prospects to fill the 12th spot.

Finally the trial got underway on July 6, 1944.

The following trial information comes from the Cincinnati Enquirer dated July 8, 1944:


The commonwealth introduced a statement taken from the 55-year- old Johnson in the hospital in which he said "L. G. Stapf shot me today. There was not a lick struck. I did not have nothing, was in my shirt sleeves.”  Johnson’s statement said that Stapf had fired at him several times.


Jane Johnson, the widow of the slain Thurman, told the court that the shooting occurred after an argument over damage done to the Johnson fields by hogs owned by Stapf.  She stated that Stapf came to their home to talk over the dispute, and he and Johnson walked out to the field to inspect the damage. When they reached a spot near the boundary of the two farms is when she heard the shots.


The Commonwealth rested its case the same day. And the trial continued the next day as the defense presented their case.


“Stapf told the court of trouble which had arisen between his son Renauld, 19, and Johnson after hogs from the Stapf farm had broken through a fence onto the adjoining property, Stapf related his son, accompanied by a 16-year-old farm worker, Ralph Bates, had driven to Greenup immediately after Johnson was said to have fired on the hogs, wounding a brood sow.


 The undertaker said he had returned to the neighborhood with his son and the Bates youth. Reaching the Johnson farm, Stapf said he got out of the car and instructed his son to drive on home.


Stapf said he offered to pay for the damage caused by the hogs, but Johnson refused to accept any money. Johnson invited him to stay for dinner, he stated, after which the two men went out to survey the broken fence.


The defendant said he offered to provide wire and posts to repair the fence if Johnson would do the work, but he would not let Renauld help because of the previous disagreement between the two.


At the mention of his son's name, Stapf said, Johnson's manner changed, and he bitterly assailed the youth. Johnson demanded to know why Renauld was not in the army, Stapf continued, and. said he would see to It that the Stapf ' youth ‘and two others around here’  went into service ‘because they are no better than my two boys.”


Stapf said in his weakened state of health, Johnson's vitriolic attack upon his son caused him to cry. He testified that through tear-filled eyes he suddenly saw Johnson advancing toward him with a knife. Drawing a revolver from his coat pocket, Stapf said, he fired, and Johnson fell at the first shot. "Then, because it was like it was all a dream," said the undertaker, "’I fired several more shots’."


On Friday July 7, 1944 after deliberating for more than five hours, the jury convicted Stapf of manslaughter and sentenced him to two years in prison.

The defense immediately requested a new trial for Stapf, but that motion was denied by Judge Parker.  Stapf was granted a 60 day stay of his two year prison sentence in order to file an appeal.  His bond was fixed at $2,000.00.

On December 12, 1944 while still awaiting his appeal, Stapf took his own life by shooting himself with a 32-caliber pistol.  It was reported that Stapf’s actions were the result of worrying over the recent death of his son-in-law Arthur Mtchell, Jr – a partner in the funeral home.

Thurman Johnson left behind a wife and six children.  His funeral was under the direction of the Carmen Funeral Home in Russell, Kentucky and he is buried at the Liberty Cemetery in Greenup. 

Stapf is buried alongside his parents and sibling at the Woodland Cemetery in Ironton, Ohio.  As for the charges against Stapf’s son Renauld, I was unable to find any more information.


Monday, October 10, 2022

Inez, Kentucky Town Marshall Joseph Kirk Gunned Down!

 Founded in 1870 and named for Congressman John Preston Martin, Martin County, Kentucky is located in Eastern Kentucky on the boarder of West Virginia.

Since its inception in 1870, Martin County, just as any county, has had its high points and its low points.  One of those low points came on Sunday, October 1, 1899.

What caused this low point in Martin County history? Well, it varies per source. But it involved the Cassadys and the Kirks, both of whom were very wealthy and prominent families in Martin County.
 
 Numerous newspapers reported that, on the day before, Henry Cassady had come to town and soon became intoxicated on moonshine. The Courier-Journal in Louisville, KY states that Cassady was looking for trouble. And in that search for trouble, he fired two unprovoked shots at Sampson Kirk. The bullets missed but the incident prompted Kirk to swear out a warrant against Cassady.  The warrant was given to Inez Town Marshal Joseph Kirk to serve.  Marshal Kirk was the nephew of victim Sampson Kirk.

clipped from the 
Louisville
Courier-Journal
October 3, 1899

Marshal Kirk rode out to the home of Henry Cassady to serve the warrants, but Cassady was not home.  However on the way back into town, Marshal Kirk met Cassady.  When he ordered Cassady under arrest, Cassady raised his Winchester rifle and shot Kirk two to three times, killing him instantly.

However, other sources report that Cassady and Kirk met up and an old political grudge started a quarrel between the two men. And as a result, Cassady shot and killed Kirk.

And yet another edition the Louisville Courier-Journal, dated December 4, 1901 stated that the murder was the result of a dispute over the mortgage on a yoke of oxen belonging to Cassady, which Kirk tried to foreclose.

And yet another source, my 11th Grade English teacher who has ancestral connections to the Cassady’s,  said that her family told her that Inez had just installed some wooden sidewalks.  And a cow belonging to Cassady had gotten out and was destroying the sidewalks. And Kirk was trying to arrest Cassady for it.  And it resulted in Cassady killing Kirk. 

Regardless of which version is the correct story, Kirk was dead and Cassady immediately fled to the mountains.  A posse was formed to search for him. Since it was believed that he had fled to West Virginia, Huntington, WV detectives were also brought in on the search. A $400 reward was offered for his capture.

Nearly two years later, on May 19, 1901, United States Marshal Cunningham returned from Clay County, West Virginia, where he had arrested Cassady near Sycamore Creek. 

Cassady confessed to the crime and then telegraphed Gov. Beckham for protection upon his return home.
Clipped from the 
Courier-Journal
May 20, 1901


Cassady was returned home to Inez, KY, the county seat of Martin County, where the trial was scheduled to begin on May 30, 1901.

Due to so much conflicting information, I’ve omitted the trial delays. I tried to sort out the facts, but it was just too confusing and unclear. So I deleted all of that.   But the trial was delayed more than once.  Finally on December 2, 1901 the trial got underway. Special Judge Segraves presided over the trial.

Clipped from 
the
Courier-Journal
Dec. 4, 1901







The details of the trial are not known, but Cassady was found guilty and was sentenced to two years in prison. (Two years seemed to be the normal sentence for murder back in the day.  A lot of the murder cases I have researched have all lead to just two year sentences.)  Cassady was given a stay of judgment for sixty days pending an appeal and was lodged in the Catlettsburg, KY jail for safekeeping during that time.  I’m assuming the appeal failed because he was in fact sentenced to the two years.

 Cassady’s trial ended up costing the state $3500.00.






 In January, 1902, according to the Louisville
Courier Journal, A petition for a pardon was circulated in Martin County. Over 700 of the 900 voters in the county signed the petition. 
clipped from the
Courier-Journal
January 18,1902



 And in October 1902, Cassady was pardoned by Governor Beckham.




clipped from the Mt. Sterling Advocate
October 8, 1902


Another strange case regarding the Cassadys:  The Courier Journal reported on January 17, 1902 that Henry’s siblings Amos and Lincoln mysteriously disappeared when they were 13 and 14 years old. They left home and were never seen or heard from again.  When their wealthy father passed away, the rest of the family attempted to find them but were unsuccessful.  But they were heirs to a fortune, according to the Courier-Journal. 




Thursday, October 6, 2022

The Murder That Could Have Started A Civil War

 

It was Saturday, July 20, 1912. And the Magoffin County, Kentucky area was reeling from the recent murder of Mack Bailey just days earlier on July 7th.   Little did they know that another murder was about to take place in their county, one that had officials concerned that it could erupt in an all out county civil war.

This particular Saturday, a fight broke out between Lee Patrick, brother of U.S. Marshal Asberry Patrick, and Ern and Clarence Arnett.  The Arnett’s and the Patricks were two very prominent families in the Magoffin County area at the time, and still are to this day. The Big Sandy News in Louisa, Kentucky reported on July 26, 1912 that young Clarence Arnett stabbed Patrick with a butcher knife, killing him instantly.

Historic Downtown Salyersville 

According to the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer, dated July 26, 1912, Lee Patrick’s wife, who was a sister of Role Minix, had left Patrick a year or so prior.  Arr Arnett, Role Minix’s father-in-law was the attorney for Patrick’s former wife.  A deal had been reached wherein Patrick was to pay $200.00.  He borrowed the money and came to town to settle the matter, only for Arr to tell him that he must pay an additional sum of $25.00 to his son Ern for services.  Patrick refused to do so.  And as a result, the trouble started.
 
The statements about the case were somewhat conflicting according to the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer.  The defense introduced no proof.   But the prosecution presented 12 witnesses.  These are their statements:

“ Some three or four months ago, I was in the law office of Arnett & Howard, and Lee Patrick was there.  They had met there for the purpose of taking depositions in the case of Lee Patrick and his wife.  Arr and Lee were talking about the case and some few words were spoken when Arr grabbed up a whet rock or weight and drew it on Lee.  I thought they were going to kill him and I had to jump up and tell them that they couldn’t all jump on him.” – Jack Minix

“On the day of the killing Mitchell Whitaker and myself were on the walk just in front of the Adams pool room.  Ern Arnett came out and said to Lee Patrick ‘come out in the street and fight me.’  Lee had not said anything to him before Ern ran out and bantered Lee.  Patrick was across the street near the curbing and he came into the street and Ern and him got within a few feet of each other.  Ern was keeping his arms going.  I couldn’t tell just where his arms were all the time.  When they got over near the pool room, Ern jumped in the pool room and Lee just afterwards.  Minix was just behind Clarence on the walk.  After t hey got in Clarence came out fast just in a second.  As Ern and them came out and Arr was there. I heard some one say don’t go in.  It’s already done.  Lee went over toward Ern like he was laughing.  I didn’t think they were going to fight.  Lee could have shot him.  Had all the chance that was necessary.” – Wiley Caldwell

“I was in the Minix pool room when Arr and Lee Patrick were having their racket.  I came out. Lee was leaving and I heard him say that was jumping on him for nothing.  After the killing or about the time of it, I saw Roll Minix coming from Adams pool room door.  He was on the walk near the stove.  He had a pistol and ran into his grocery”. – Bascom Prater

“I was on the walk in front of Minix grocery and the first thing I heard or saw was some people going in the pool room. I couldn’t tell who went in first.  I saw Roll Minix come running out of his store with a pistol and heard a woman tell him to shoot him.  I saw Clarence Arnett come out of the pool room.  I went up and looked in.  A crowd was in there.  I then got on a horse and started after Jack Patrick.  Just across the bridge I met Maurice Minix coming with a gun, and on the walk I saw a man just above there hide a gun under the walk at John Hale’s and he asked me if Lee Patrick was killed.” – Bill McPherson.

“I was in the Minix grocery a short time before the killing.  Andy Meade and myself.  We were back by the lemonade stand.  There was some excitement out in the street.  Roll Minix seemed to be excited and called to Clarence Arnett to come there quick.  Clarence and Roll whispered a minute and Clarence went in a fast walk back behind something in the store.  I heard a noise in there like he was turning over something.  Then he came out and he and Roll went out on the walk.  I then saw Clarence with a hammer.  This was just a short time before the killing.” – Billy Phipps.

“Saw Ern come out of the pool room after the killing and heard him say, ‘The damned son of a b—‘.” – Farish Lacey

“I was standing on the curbing near the bell tower.  The racket came up over about the pool room.  I looked and saw Roll Minix come out of his grocery with a pistol and a woman hollowing ‘shoot him, Roll, shoot him.’” – Virgil Patrick

“I was in the pool room when the racket came up.  I was engaged in the game.  My attention was first attracted by hearing talking on the outside.  I looked and saw Ern Arnett come out in the street and hollow something to Lee, who was across the street.  Lee said something that I did not understand.  They then started out and were meeting each other.  I saw Lee like he was pulling up his sleeves.  When they got near the door Ern jumped up in the door and around by the side of the cashier.  Lee put his hand back like he had a pistol and jumped in the door.  I jumped out the window and ran around to the back door and looked in and saw J.L. Arnett pulling Ern off Lee.” – George Anderson

“I was on the walk near the upper window of the pool room.  Ern Arnett came out of the Minix Grocery and out in the street.  The first thing I heard was Ern said to Lee, ‘G—D--- you, I can whip you.  Lee started across the street walking along and they got close together, and I saw Ern back a shot distance and Lee had his hand like he had a pistol.  Ern jumped up in the door and Lee just behind him.  I thought I would grab Lee but I saw Roll Minix and Arr Arnett coming up and I thought I had better not interfere in their racket.  I don’t know that I saw Clarence go in.  I saw someone, some small fellow run in after Lee.  I saw Clarence come out just after the killing. When I saw Minix, he had something. I took it to be a pistol.” – Dud Howington

“About fifteen minutes before the racket in which the killing occurred I heard Arnett and Lee Patrick having some words.  I heard Arr call him a rascal and a dog and several vile names.  Lee said ‘that is all right what you say just so you keep your hands off of me.’” – J. Press Adams.

“I heard a woman scream across the street and I saw Ern Arnett and Lee Patrick in front of the pool room, Ern over next to the pool room.  Lee had his hand back like he was going to pull a pistol.  Ern said ‘don’t you do that, and Florence Minix said ‘shoot him’, ‘kill him’, or words to that effect. Ern was in the pool room and Lee was going in  at the door when Clarence Arnett ran up and caught him with one hand and I took it to be a small sized butcher knife in his hand. They then disasppeared in the pool room.” – J.B. Bailey

“I was in the pool room and the first thing I saw was Lee Patrick in the door, or just inside, and Clarence Arnett just behind him.  They were in kind of a tussle.  About that time Ern Arnett closed him and had his arms around Lee and Clarence ran up and made a lick and run.  Ern and Lee then went down on the floor and Ern was on top and Ern was striking him with his fist.  While they were on the floor standing I heard Lee groan or make a  noise like a sick person, then they went down and I heard him groan twice more while Ern was  on him.” – Frank Anderson

“I was in the Adams pool room.  I heard some loud talking on the outside and recognized Ern Arnett’s voice.  I heard him invite Lee Patrick to fight him.  Lee said something and laughed.   Ern started at him and got within a few feet of Lee and Lee put his hand back like he had a pistol.  They got near the pool room door and Ern got up in the door and got over next to the counter on the right side.  Lee then came up in the door and Clarence after him.  As soon as Lee entered the room, Ern closed him and had around his arms and Clarence ran in while Ern was holding him and stabbed him in the breast with a large knife.  Lee then sunk down or he and Ern fell on the floor and Ern commenced to strike him in the face with his fist.  A short time before the killing my brother,  Will Crace, and me come down the walk near  the pool room.  Lee Patrick and Arr Arnett were having some words.  I heard Lee say, ‘Arr you got mad at me for nothing. Go on, I don’t want any trouble with you.’ “ – Jim Crace

Within a few minutes Deputy Sheriff Jackson L. Arnett arrested Ern Arnett, Arr Arnett, Clarence Arnett, Arby Arnett, and Roll Minix and put them in jail.

As word of the killing spread through the community, the talk of more violence began to fill the streets. Due to the prominence of both families, it was feared that the trouble would erupt into an all out county civil war.   This prompted Judge Gardner to place the state guards around the jail on Saturday and they remained there until Tuesday.  

Judge Salyer set Clarence Arnett’s bond at $3,000 and Ern Arnett’s bond at $2,500.00. He acquitted Arr Arnett and Roll Minix.  The Arnett’s bond was filled and they were again at  large.
 
Lee Patrick became the sixth man to be murdered in Magoffin County in a 12 month period. The other five were Leck Whitt, Buddy Whitt, James Harper, Samuel P’Simer, and Mack Bailey.  And according to the Hazel Green Herald, as reported by the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer dated August 2, 1912, it was a brutal one.    The Herald allegedly reported that the Arnetts held Patrick and “literally cut his body to pieces”. It went on to say that they severed his heart. 

The exact dates vary per source, but sometime in September 1912, Ern Arnett, Clarence Arnett, and R.C. Minix were indicted for the murder of Patrick.  They tried for bail and the Arnetts were granted bail of $5,000 each and Minix was granted bail of $2,500.   The Commonwealth requested a change of venue, and it was granted.  The trial was moved to Mt. Sterling, KY (Montgomery County) and it was scheduled to get underway in January 1913.

January rolled around and the trial was postponed until the April 1913 term of the court due to the defense not being ready for trial.  According to the Courier-Journal in Louisville, KY (January 24, 1913 edition), 25 witnesses were called for the defense and 35 witnesses for the Commonwealth.  Witness claims aggregated a cost of $1,024.  It was predicted at the time that the trial would cost the state $5,000.00.

On April 15, 1913 the trial of Clarence Arnett began in Mt. Sterling, KY. By this time the witness count had climbed to more than 100 people.   Clarence was charged with conspiring with his brother Ern and R.C. Minix to kill Lee Patrick.

 According to the Louisville Courier-Journal, dated April 16, 1913, Jury members chosen to hear the trial were B.F.Perry, Harry Campbell, A.B. Oldham, R.E. Tipton, James Leach, Lester Lee, W.E. Sledd, James Montjoy, Charles Fogg, R.C. Robinson, Elson Wills, and Ewell Payne.

The defense was represented by William A. Young of Morehead, KY, Floyd Byrd of Lexington, KY, Judge E.C. O’Rear of Frankfort, Henry R. Prewit and C.W. Nesbitt of Mt. Sterling.  The Commonwealth Attorney W.B. White was assisted by County Attorney E.W. Senff, R.A. Chiles, and United States District Attorney Edward P. Morrow of Covington,KY.

Three days later on April 18, 1913, Clarence was acquitted by the jury after just 30 minutes of deliberation.

The trial of Ernest “Ern” Arnett was scheduled to begin a year later on April 16, 1914.  However due to the absence of witnesses and of prosecutor Edward P. Morrow, it was moved to September of that year.
And on September 24, 1914, Ern too was acquitted.

All efforts to find the outcome of the trial of R.C. Minix were unsuccessful.

Lee was laid to rest in the Francis Patrick Cemetery.

Augustus “Ar” Arnett died in 1922, his son Ern died in 1942, and Clarence died in 1970.

This brought about the end of another sad chapter in Magoffin County’s history.


Sunday, September 11, 2022

The Chain of Murder: The Murder of Dave Wireman & The Events Leading Up To It

 

The summer of 1931 brings us back to Magoffin County, Kentucky, the scene of yet another murder.

When the news first broke, the reports stated that two men and two women were gunned down as they worked in the fields.  However investigators would learn that was not the case at all.  But let’s start from the beginning.

In 1929, Frank Johnson was charged with the murder of Frank Shepherd in Floyd County, KY.  And allegedly, he was also suspected in the robbery and murder of Nelson Hale in Magoffin County, KY that same year.  And he was wanted for a number of other robberies in the area. However, I was unable to find any details on either of the two murders.  But because of these murders, Mr. Johnson was on the run and had been wanted for more than two years.

On June 2, 1931, a posse lead by Floyd Wireman set out in search of Frank. When they found him, a shootout erupted and Frank Johnson was killed along with posse member Brack Pinks.   It was believed that Robert Johnson, brother of Frank, was wounded in the shootout but he managed to escape.

Dave Wireman, 
courtesy of Find-a-Grave

The next week, Dave Wireman was working in the fields when he was ambushed and shot.  Initial reports stated that four members of the Wireman family had been shot, but that proved to be untrue.

The Louisville Courier-Journal reported on June 11, 1931 that Wireman and his 7 year old son James were in the field working when the ambush occurred.  The shot, which came from a brush pile, came from a revolver. The bullet entered Wireman’s left chest. He died instantly, according to a report published on June 10, 1931 in the Kentucky Post and Times-Star in Covington, KY.  A second shot whizzed by James. James jumped into a creek and took cover.  After the threat had passed, he ran home and reported what had happened.

Police believe that Robert Johnson was responsible for the murder of Wireman, in revenge for the slaying of his brother Frank a week prior. Mr. Wireman and his son Floyd both had been a part of the posse that had killed Frank.

Immediately after the murder of Wireman, bloodhounds were brought in from Lexington to assist a posse in their search for Johnson.  Here is a report, copied and pasted directly from the Lexington Herald, Lexington, KY, July 12, 1931, in reference to the hunt. Oddly, it was the only article that I found that stated another reason for the killing:

“A thrilling chase of an outlaw-killer through  the mountainous country of Magoffin county was told by W R Sebree,  who returned to Lexington yesterday after having taken his bloodhounds 20 miles east Of Salyersvllle in an effort to capture the murderer  of Dave Wireman,  who was killed from ambush at Ordway Tuesday. 

According to Mr. Sebree, his hounds took up the trail of the murderer from the scene of the killing In a field where Wireman and his 14-year-old son, Jimmie Wireman, were working and followed the fugitive to a mountain around which a posse of approximately 300 men is now stationed awaiting the appearance of the killer.

 Mr. Sebree said that Robert Johnson, 28 years old, is accused of the killing and Sheriff Adam Carpenter, of Magoffin County, had ordered the posse to shoot to kill if he made his appearance on the mountain.

Wireman, who was postmaster at Ordway, is said to have gained the enmity of Johnson when he testified against him in a liquor case. Following the shooting Tuesday, a note was found on a tree near the scene of the murder in which the writer stated that he intended to kill three other persons.

 The murderer of Wireman also fired several shots at Jimmie Wireman when he attempted to reach his father after he had fallen. Panic stricken, the boy ran to his home and notified other members of the family of the shooting.   Fearing that others might be killed, no attempt was made to get the body of the elder Wireman until a posse had been formed several hours later.

During the man hunt which was carried out all day Wednesday,  Mr. Sebree said that several times the hounds were so close upon the fugitive that his footstep could be heard, but that they could not reach him because of the thick mountain undergrowth.”

And sadly, this is where the story ends.  I searched extensively trying to find out if Johnson was ever caught and brought to justice.  But just as the posse’s efforts were in vain, so were mine.

I want to thank Sharon Wireman Holiday for making me aware of this case.  I hope my research, as brief as the findings are, filled in some of the blanks for you and your family.


Saturday, September 10, 2022

Charles Manson: His Kentucky Roots Run Deep!

 

Charles Manson

I normally don’t do two blogs in one day.  And I do have a more serious case to investigate for a blog that I will be starting soon.  But this subject once again came up on a social media group earlier this week.  And as always it was full of mistruths and rumors.  So I thought that I would do a short blog to hopefully once and for all shed some light on Charles Manson and his Kentucky ties.

Last year I learned that Manson was my 9th cousin once removed. Though very distant, when I found there was a little bit of an ancestral connection I began digging into Manson’s Kentucky beginnings.

I am eliminating names here because I don’t want folks going around  vandalizing graves simply because someone was related to Manson.  And yes there are idiots out there that would do that.

 But Charles Manson, for all intents and purposes, was a Kentucky boy. He spent time here, and his roots run deep here.

Charles was born in Cincinnati, Ohio.  His mother was born in Rowan County (Morehead), KY.   Her parents resided in Rowan County before eventually migrating to Ashland, KY. In fact Charles’ maternal grandmother was born in Rowan County as well, and his maternal grandfather was born in Elliott County, KY.

One of the homes in Ashland, KY
where Charles lived for a while.

I don't have a timeline of when they actually moved from Morehead. But I know they lived for a while in the Grahn community in Carter County. And according to Ron Daley of the "Troublesome Creek Times" in Hindman, the family arrived in Ashland when Charles' mother was ten years old. Her parents stayed there and apparently died there because that is where they are buried. 


 Charles Manson's Maternal Great Grandparents, Great-Great Grandparents, and Great Great Great Grandparents were from Carter County, KY and are buried there. His 4th Great Grandfather was born in Richmond, KY and is buried in Carter County.


The Home of
Charles Manson's Father
that used to stand in
Catlettsburg, KY

Manson's biological father was born in Pike County, KY and resided and  is buried in Catlettsburg, KY in Boyd County.  Manson's Paternal Grandfather is from Pike County, KY and is buried in Catlettsburg Cemetery as well along with his wife.


Manson's paternal Great-Grandparents and Great-Great Grandparents are buried in Pike County, KY.


Author Willie Davis stated in his book “Ghost Towns of 174” that Manson recounted in a San Quentin video about spending time in Morehead just before heading to the West Coast.  Charles also said in a letter to Ron Daley "I stomped all over Ky."



The former Blue Moon Cafe
Knott County, KY. Charles & his mother
lived upstairs for a short time.


 For a brief period of time, Charles & his mother lived in Knott County, KY where she worked at the Blue Moon Cafe. She worked downstairs in the bar - and they lived upstairs. Charles said that he was 5 or 6 years old at the time.  
Charles went on to describe Hindman as a "law and order border town," and said that "it's true that you can't take the hills out of the boy." That building, though rapidly falling into despair thanks to vandalism after Charlie’s passing, is for sale.





 In closing I want to clear up on rumor that I have heard time and time again.  And that is the rumor that Manson and his family killed his Uncle in Ashland, Kentucky.  That is not true.  Yes, he was a suspect for a brief time.  But the Los Angeles Police Department was able to prove that Manson was NOT in Kentucky at the time of his uncle’s murder.



So I hope this clears up some misconceptions and rumors about Manson’s Kentucky roots.

Dennis "Dennie" Saylor: The Bloody Trail Continues

 In my last blog, I told you to remember the name Dennie Saylor because you would see that name again.  Well now his bloody trail continues.


After we posted our last blog, “The Murder of Mack Bailey In Magoffin County, Kentucky”, I was able to find a single newspaper clipping stating that Dennie’s brothers Dock and Bob, along with Archie Johnson, were charged with the murder of Mack Bailey’s younger brother Taylor Bailey, Jr. in 1932. 

Then Dennie’s trail again goes cold in my sources. Well, until 1929 anyway.

Dennie Saylor
courtesy of the
Courier-Journal & 
Anna Saylor Case

On April 30, 1929, Dennie’s name returns to the headlines for yet another murder.  The Louisville Courier-Journal reports the events in this manner, which I’ve summarized:  The Johnson County Sheriff made his way into the hills to investigate reports of a shooting.  As he was going in, he met a horse-drawn sled carrying four bodies, two men, a woman, and a boy as well as a wounded man.  All apparently were victims of a drunken argument.

The deceased were Wallace Hannah, age 34; Lee Gibson, age 45, his wife Cassie Gibson, age 35, and their son, Bernie Gibson, age 14.  The wounded man was Wayne Hannah, brother of Wallace Hannah.

Dennie Saylor was later arrested in connection with the shooting, even though he had been shot through the arm.

Officers began trying to fit the pieces of the puzzle together to hopefully determine the cause of the tragedy.  According to statements from both Wayne Hannah, and Dennie Saylor, Lee Gibson, his son Bernie, Wallace & Wayne Hannah had been working in the field and were waiting for Dennie to bring a plow from Riceville.  While they were waiting they drank some moonshine.  When Saylor arrived with the plow, they offered him some of the moonshine, which he accepted.


 According to their statements, Lee Gibson and Wallace Hannah both were running for school trustee of their district, and some angry words were exchanged.  Both men suggested that the other should withdraw from the race.  Wayne stated that he thought the argument had been settled and turned to leave. As he turned to leave, he said someone started shooting.

Both Saylor and Wayne claimed that neither of them had a gun.  A pistol holster was found on Gibson but there was no gun in it. 

Saylor was questioned by the Grand Jury.

Cassie Gibson’s part in the tragedy was never revealed but she had been shot in the head.  Bernie Gibson, their son, was shot in the back as he ran.  Lee Gibson had been shot in the chest.  Wallace Hannah was shot in the right side.   And Wayne Hannah was shot in the right lung.
Neighbors were so frightened by the shooting that they did not go to the scene until the next day. And that is when the bodies were discovered.

Saylor was arrested on four counts of murder and one count of shooting and wounding, and was taken to the Paintsville jail.  On May 2, 1929, he was indicted by the grand jury on all accounts. It was during the grand jury’s three day investigation that Saylor’s son, Columbus Saylor, testified that his dad had returned home and said that he had “killed the whole damned bunch.”

 Dennie was later removed to the jail in Winchester, KY for safe keeping according to May 3, 1929 edition of the Sun Democrat in Paducah, Kentucky.

The June 11, 1929 edition of the Owensboro Messenger-Inquirer reported that the death penalty would be sought for Saylor.  The article also stated that in addition to the argument over the school election, an argument over a moonshine still was also a part of the cause of the tragedy.   That same article stated that the defense said they would prove that Saylor’s gun was at his home at the time of the shooting and that he was not armed.

The June 12, 1929 edition of the Owensboro Messenger-Inquirer reported that jury selections were underway for the trial.  And it stated that it had been recalled during that day that Saylor had been tried in Magoffin County in 1919 for the murder of McClelland Bailey and was sentenced to the penitentiary but was later freed by the Court of Appeals which held that the evidence did not show that he had any part in the killing.  Interestingly I found no records of that murder in my searching other than this one article.

Interestingly, the Louisville Courier-Journal reported on June 12, 1929 that the jury that was chosen for the trial was discharged as soon as it was completed.  A.J. Kirk, counsel for the defendant moved for the dismissal on grounds that the jury had been summoned for jury service in February and were used for a special term of the court in April.  Judge J.F. Bailey granted the motion.

On June 13, 1929, as reported by the June 14, 1929 edition of the News-Democrat in Paducah, KY, Dennie Saylor, who had plead not guilty, was released from the Johnson County Jail on $30,000 bail and the case was continued until the October 1929 term of the court.

Although the trial was scheduled for October 1929, it actually did not start until November 15, 1929 according to a report from the Paducah Sun Democrat, dated November 16, 1929.  This trial was for the murder of 14 year old Bernie Gibson. As previously stated Saylor pleaded not guilty. And the Commonwealth Attorney was seeking the death penalty. 

Wayne Hannah, who was shot in the fray, testified that the slaying occurred as a result of an argument over a moonshine still and an election dispute.  In fact, both Hannah and Saylor agreed that an election dispute started as they were drinking in the field. According to Wayne Hannah's story, Saylor seized Lee Gibson's gun and killed all four.

Saylor on the other hand testified that Gibson, having a 38-caliber pistol, was the only one he saw armed, although he noticed Wayne Hannah make a hip-pocket motion. Gibson and Wayne Hannah engaged in a fist fight, Saylor explained, and he grabbed Gibson and pulled him away. He said Mrs. Gibson came and tried to take her husband home, but he refused to go, and Wallace Hannah urged him to remain.

Then Mrs. Gibson, the defendant testified, took a pistol from her husband's holster and fired al Wallace Hannah. Saylor said that he “tried to grab the gun and my hand was powder burned.  I then ran down the hill and don't know who did the other shooting. I went home and took my wife and children to my father's home for the night. I did not stop to tell the families of the people shot because l did not want to get mixed up in it. I did tell my father, brother and uncle."

Hallie Blanton was called to the stand by the Commonwealth and testified concerning powder burns on the body of Mrs. Gibson, who she said, was shot in the face and back.

Mrs Wallace Hannah was recalled to the stand and questioned briefly concerning previous testimony.  Mrs. Wallace Hannah detailed to the jury that her brother-in-law, Wayne Hannah, was the last person to go up on the hilltop of Saylor’s farm.  She stated that he rode a mule and carried a quart jar, which she believed contained moonshine.  Her husband, Wallace, later brought the mule down the hill and went back, saying that he was afraid Lee Gibson would kill his brother, Wayne.

According to Mrs. Hannah, sixteen shots were fired.  Bernie Gibson called her to come, as they were “all being killed,” but she was afraid to go.

Dr. Morris Price described the wounds of the slain and exhibited bullets that he had taken from the bodies.  All were shot in the back with .38-calibur bullets.  According to the prosecution, Salyor was the only one who did any shooting, his pistol being a .38-calibur.  The prosecution also stated that all the victims had been shot in the back as they were running. Some newspaper accounts stated that Hannah testified that his wound was from Cassie Gibson, that she shot him before dying from wounds of her own.

 It was also revealed in the trial that Sheriff H.E. Adams found two stills on Saylor’s farm.
It was also stated that the bodies lay out in the field overnight because neighbors were afraid to venture to the location that day of the slaying.  Officers called to the scene the following day met the neighbors carrying the bodies on the farm sled.

On November 18, 1929, the jury convicted Dennie Saylor for the murder of Bernie Gibson. He was sentenced to 18 years in prison.
 
Just days after being convicted for the murder of Bernie Gibson, Saylor went on trial for the murder of Lee Gibson.  Not much information from that trial could be found other than Mitchell Blair and his wife testified that they saw Dennie Saylor with Lee Gibson’s pistol after the shooting.  In my research I was not able to find the outcome of this trial, or that of the trials for the murders of the other two victims, if there was in fact a trial for them.

This concludes the bloody trail of Dennie Saylor, at least for now.   I was told that he was linked to another murder after these, but I was unable to find proof of that.

Tuesday, September 6, 2022

The Murder of Mack Bailey of Magoffin County, Kentucky

Sunday July 7, 1912 was unlike most Sabbath days, well, at least in Magoffin County, Kentucky anyway.   Most Sundays are filled with prayers and thanksgiving, and family.  But on this particular Sunday, Bud Collins left church with one mission in mind – to kill 19 year old Mack Bailey.

The July 12, 1912 edition of the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer described the events of the day, and we have summarized their report here.

The trouble between the two began months before over a baseball game.  But they had had no further trouble until they both began calling on the same girl.   The young lady, who was never identified, at least in my sources, had previously turned Collins down for Bailey.  And on this particular Sunday after church, she once again turned down Collins’ offer to go with him.  Collins became irate and responded “I’ll kill Mack Bailey!”

Collins climbed on his mule and fired one shot with his revolver as he took off toward the creek.  He had persuaded Dennie Saylor to accompany him.

They came upon Mack Bailey, his younger brother Taylor, age 15, and 18 year old Charley Adams in neighboring Johnson County.  Collins dismounted and pulled his gun on Mack saying “D--- you if you speak, I will shoot you!”  Bailey never moved or said a word, according to my source.  Collins fired at Bailey, the fatal shot hitting him above his right eye.

Immediately, Taylor Bailey and Charley Adams grabbed Collins.  When they released him, Collins fired at the young Adams, who fell to the ground and pretended to be dead. Collins then started after Taylor Bailey, but Taylor took his dead brothers revolver and emptied it at Collins.  Collins ran back up the road. 

Collins received a stab in the neck during the altercation and had lost a great deal of blood.  He went to the home of his uncle Nelson Collins and had the wound dressed. Then he and his uncle and others fled into the woods.  Nelson was reported as saying that they would die before they would be taken.

The next day, R.C. Salyer, the acting County Judge of Magoffin County petitioned the Governor, who In return, sent 20 militiamen to Magoffin County to arrest Collins.  However, two days later, the troops were withdrawn.  The reason for the withdrawal was costs. Acting Governor McDermott and Acting Adjutant General Tandy Ellis stated that it would be cheaper for them to offer a reward for Collins’ capture than to provide manpower for the search.  However, they said, if he was found and was putting up an armed resistance to authorities, the militiamen may remain. 

The day after the shooting, County Jailer Henry Brown and Floyd Patrick tracked down Dennie Saylor and arrested him. He was taken to the county jail where he was awaiting an examining trial.
By this time, Mack Bailey’s two brothers, Eddie and Fred, also joined in the search for Collins.
According to the July 19, 1912 edition of the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer, The examining trial for Dennie Salyor was held on Monday, July 15, 1912.  The newspaper reported that he was acquitted in the murder of Mack Bailey.  There’s more to come on that later. 

Johnson County Sheriff brought Nelson Collins, who assisted his nephew Bud Collins in his escape, to Magoffin County authorities.  Nelson waived the examining trial and filled a bond of $1,000.00 and returned to his home.

As for Bud Collins, he was still at large and authorities had no clue as to his whereabouts.   It was believed that a reward would produce Collins.  The reward started at $250 but eventually grew to more than $750.00 by 1925, which was considered a large amount of money in those days.  It would be the equivalent of $12,698.00 today.  But despite the large sum of reward money, Collins could not be found.

 News of the murder by this time had made its way around the region.  And on July 28, 1912, Letcher County official John D. Collins arrested a man near Whitesburg.  This was reported by both the Louisville Courier-Journal (July 30, 1912) and the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer (August 2, 1912).  The man was said to be Bud Collins. However, the man denied being Collins. He was taken to Jenkins, KY where he was examined and released.  This would not be the only person thought to be Bud Collins. We will talk about that a little bit later.

Bud Collins may have been on the run, but his sympathizers let their presence be known when on December 10, 1912, the home of James Howes was burned.  According to the Big Sandy News (December 13, 1912), the home and the entire contents were destroyed except for one bookshelf.   As Mr. Howes was leaving the remains of the house, a stone was hurled at him from the hillside. It was later reported that Howes’ home was burned because he spoke out against Bud Collins over the murder of Mack Bailey.

Old Magoffin County
 Courthouse (1890-1957)

According to the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer’s May 2, 1913 edition, Dennie Saylor was tried for aiding Bud Collins in killing Mack Bailey the week prior.  Eight of the jury was for convicting and four for acquitting.  Under the instructions given to the jury, a conviction would have been either a life sentence or death.

The December 4, 1913 edition of the Louisville Courier-Journal reported that on December 3, 1913, it was ruled by the Court of Appeals that the lower court, the Magoffin Circuit Court erred in refusing instructions.  The court had refused the request of the Commonwealth to instruct the jury as to the crime of voluntary manslaughter, and the trial resulted in a hung jury. Then the Commonwealth asked for a certification of the law in regard to the instructions.

The Court of Appeals said under the statement of facts Saylor was entitled to instructions as to the crime of voluntary manslaughter, and would have been entitled to a reversal of the judgment if he had been convicted, wherefore the Commonwealth was entitled to such instructions.

The January 30, 1914 edition of the Big Sandy News in Louisa, KY reported that Dennie Saylor was convicted by the Magoffin Circuit Court for conspiring with Bud Collins to kill Mack Bailey.  The sentence was 2 to 21 years.  But, according to the Louisville Courier-Journal, May 9, 1914 edition, on May 8, 1914, he was granted a new trial by the Court of Appeals with instructions that if no better case is made against Saylor, a verdict in his favor shall be directed.  It is here that the guilt or innocence of Dennie Saylor goes cold, as I could not find any further information on the new trial.   But remember his name, because you will read more about him more blogs in the near future.

On October 20, 1924, twelve years after the murder of Mack Bailey, a man who was supposed to be Bud Collins was arrested in Ashland, Kentucky, according to the Lexington Leader of the same date.  It was believed that during the 1912 skirmish, that one of the bullets struck Collins in the hip and had left a scar.

Magoffin County officials examined the man and found the scar on the hip, but were unable to positively identify the man as being Bud Collins, based solely on the scar and his features. After all, twelve years had passed.    However, the man state to police that he would be mobbed if he was returned to Magoffin County, and that he would die first. 

After three days in jail, the man was identified as S.A. Marting, and was freed, according to the Lexington Leader, dated October 22, 1924.

On February 11, 1925, the News-Democrat in Paducah, Kentucky reported that Governor Fields offered $250.00 reward for the arrest and conviction of Bud Collins.  Added to the $500 that Mack Bailey’s father had put up, that brought the total reward to $750.00.  But Collins was never found. This was the last mention of him or the murder that I could find in my sources.  Was the man arrested in Ashland really Bud Collins?  I have a strong feeling that it was.  But we will never know. Only a few editions of the Salyersville Kentucky Mountaineer are available, specifically 1912-14.  And I was unable to find anything else on any of the other resources I have.  It's very possible that Collins was eventually captured, but it's also a possibility that he wasn't.

Forgotten Kentucky: The Day a Fighter Plane Chased a UFO Over Fort Knox

  Courtesy of The Morehead Minute Newsletter: By Joe Clark For The Morehead Minute Long before The X-Files , before Project Blue Book becam...