On a summer morning in 1949, a quiet street in downtown Grayson, Kentucky, became the scene of a violent confrontation that shocked Carter County residents. What began as a simple question about a debt quickly escalated into a stabbing that nearly cost a man his life and eventually sent an elderly farmer to prison.
The case of Jarvey Lee Roark and R. E. “Bob” Biggs remains one of the more unusual criminal episodes in Carter County history—not only because of the violence involved, but because the man convicted of the attack was already in his eighties.
A Meeting on Main Street
On Saturday morning, June 4, 1949, Jarvey Lee Roark and his wife were standing outside Botts Drug Store in downtown Grayson when they encountered Robert E. “Bob” Biggs, a well-known Carter County farmer.
Roark, a 44-year-old truck driver and farmer, had done hauling work for Biggs and claimed he was owed money. According to testimony later presented in court, Roark simply approached Biggs and asked if the money had been left for him at the bank.
Biggs reportedly replied that he had not yet received his check and promised that Roark would get his payment the following week.
Roark accepted the answer and turned to walk away.
What happened next stunned witnesses.
Without warning, Biggs drew a knife and stabbed Roark in the left side of the neck.
The attack occurred in full view of people gathered along the street.
Witness Tracy Hall later testified that he saw Biggs strike Roark with the knife while Roark’s back was turned. Others nearby—Mrs. Eloise Crawford, Harry Clark, Clay Taylor, James MacMillan, and Ora Everman—corroborated key parts of the account.
“Bleeding Terrible”
Roark’s wife, Dixie Roark, witnessed the entire attack.
She later testified that after her husband turned away from Biggs, the elderly man suddenly lunged forward and stabbed him.
Jarvey Roark began bleeding heavily almost immediately.
Dixie screamed and ran between the two men, pushing her husband backward while Biggs stepped toward them. Blood flowed down Roark’s body to his belt as she struggled to hold him upright.
The injured man was rushed to a hospital in Grayson, where Dr. J. W. Stovall treated the wound.
The knife had missed Roark’s jugular vein by a narrow margin but had cut muscles and a nerve in the neck. The injuries required deep sutures to stop the bleeding.
Even after treatment, Roark faced permanent damage.
According to the doctor, the wound would likely leave him with lasting stiffness and partial paralysis in the neck.
Roark remained hospitalized for eight days.
The Arrest of an Elderly Farmer
Police soon arrested R. E. “Bob” Biggs, a man described in newspaper accounts as a well-known Carter County farmer.
Despite his advanced age—82 years old at the time of sentencing—he was charged with cutting and wounding with intent to kill.
Authorities said the altercation occurred near the First National Bank in Grayson, where Roark had stopped Biggs to ask about payment of the debt.
Biggs was released on $1,000 bond while awaiting action by the Carter County grand jury.
Two Very Different Stories
At trial, the two men told very different stories about what happened that morning.
Roark’s Version
Roark testified that he simply asked Biggs if the money had been left at the bank.
Biggs said it had not and promised payment later.
Roark said he accepted that answer and turned to leave.
As he turned away, Biggs suddenly stabbed him.
Roark denied threatening Biggs or making any aggressive move toward him.
He also denied calling Biggs names or reaching for a weapon.
Biggs’ Defense
Biggs claimed he acted in self-defense.
According to his testimony, Roark confronted him angrily and accused him of refusing to pay the debt.
Biggs told the court Roark cursed him and threatened violence.
He said Roark asked if he had a knife and then appeared to reach toward his hip pocket as if grabbing a weapon.
Believing he was about to be attacked, Biggs pulled a small pocketknife—about two and a half inches long—and cut Roark.
Biggs insisted he struck only once and stopped immediately after seeing the blood.
“I didn’t want to cut him,” he testified. “But I seen I couldn’t get away from him.”
The Jury’s Decision
The jury in Carter Circuit Court ultimately believed the prosecution’s version of events.
They found Biggs guilty of malicious cutting and wounding.
Judge Roscoe Littleton sentenced the elderly farmer to 12 years in prison.
The case attracted considerable attention because of Biggs’ age and his standing in the community.
Newspaper reports described him as an 82-year-old bachelor who lived on a farm near Gregoryville with a blind brother.
The Civil Lawsuit
The criminal case was not the end of the legal battle.
Jarvey Roark later filed a civil suit seeking $15,000 in damages for the injuries he suffered.
In February 1950, a Carter County Circuit Court jury awarded Roark $4,500 in damages for the knife wounds he sustained during the attack.
Biggs Appeals
Biggs appealed his criminal conviction, arguing several errors had occurred during the trial.
His attorneys claimed:
-
The court should have granted a continuance so he could better prepare his defense.
-
Certain evidence had been improperly admitted or rejected.
-
The jury had not been properly instructed on the law of self-defense.
-
The 12-year sentence was excessive and influenced by passion or prejudice.
The Kentucky Court of Appeals reviewed the record but ultimately rejected these arguments.
The court found:
-
Biggs had ample time to prepare his defense.
-
No prejudicial evidence had been admitted improperly.
-
The jury instructions on self-defense were consistent with established law.
-
The injuries inflicted on Roark were serious and could easily have been fatal.
The court concluded the verdict was supported by the evidence.
The conviction was affirmed.
A Near-Fatal Encounter
The 1949 stabbing left a lasting mark on both men.
Roark survived the attack but suffered permanent physical effects from the severed nerve in his neck.
Biggs, despite his advanced age, was sentenced to spend more than a decade in prison.
The incident also served as a reminder of how quickly a routine encounter could turn violent—even in a small Appalachian town where nearly everyone knew each other.
On an ordinary summer morning in Grayson, a dispute over a simple debt nearly ended in tragedy.
Instead, it became one of the more memorable criminal cases in Carter County’s history.


