Saturday, October 21, 2023

The Automobile Duel of Phelps, Kentucky

 
This is another one of those cases that for whatever reason just jumped out at me. I felt that I had to cover it even though I had very little information on it. So here is the story of the Phelps, Kentucky Automobile Duel. 

The Owensboro Messenger

Owensboro, Kentucky • 

Page 4




When it comes to duels, most people don't think about automobiles being used in those.  But on September 18, 1927, that is exactly what happened in the small Pike County, Kentucky town of Phelps.


The conflict between Phelps, Kentucky policeman Blaine Bowling and former Pike County teacher and Army veteran Francis Marion "F.M." Ball began around August 1927 when Bowling allegedly searched Ball for liquor. And the grudge turned deadly on September 18, 1927.

Francis Marion "F.M." Ball


Very little information is available regarding this incident other than two newspaper articles that I found.  But based on what information we found in the Messenger-Inquirer in Owensboro, KY, dated September 19, 1927, the story goes like this:


Headline from the Messenger-Inquirer 
September 19, 1927.

"When their automobiles met on Blackberry Creek, near Ransom, 35 miles from Pikeville Sunday, F. M. Ball was shot and killed by Blaine, after he had shot Bowling through the left arm. 


Bowling is a policeman at Phelps Ky. About a month ago, Bowling is alleged to have searched Ball for liquor, and it is said that this brought about yesterday's affair.


According to reports, Ball stopped his automobile and began shooting at Bowling as Bowling's car came alongside, firing eight or ten times. Only one shot took effect. Bowling emptied his pistol at Ball, the fatal shot penetrating his side and passing through the body. Bowling was accompanied here by Officer Blackburn of Pond Creek and placed in jail.  


Ball was a former teacher in the Pike County schools."

In October 1927, Bowling was tried and sentenced to ten years in prison for the murder of Ball.  He appealed that conviction but on April 30, 1929, the Court of Appeals upheld the conviction and the 10 year sentence. 

Clipped from the Courier-Journal, Louisville, KY
May 1, 1929.



Not much else is known about Blaine Bowling. His trail goes cold after this.  

Ball was buried in the Ball Family Cemetery on Pinson Fork in Pike County, KY.  He left behind a wife and two children. 


The application for the U.S. Government
Headstone for Francis M. Ball.

The Headstone of Francis Marion Ball
courtesy of Paul Phillips / Find-A-Grave

Saturday, October 14, 2023

The History of Ellisville, Kentucky

 Have you ever passed through a community and asked yourself "I wonder what it's history is?"   I do that sometimes. And one of the communities I've had that thought about is Ellisville located in Nicholas County, KY.  Now I've only passed through Ellisville a handful of times.  But each time I have, when I see the "Ellisville" road sign I start thinking about its history. How did the community start? Where did it get its name? What businesses were here?  All those types of questions.

The small road sign coming into Ellisville.

Ellisville, formerly Ellis Station, is located on Hwy 68, better known as the Lexington-Maysville Road on what used to be the James Ellis farm.  Ellisville became the first county seat of Nicholas County in 1805.


According to Riley Mola's post on Findagrave.com, " prior to 1782, James Ellis built a log tavern to protect himself and other pioneers from the attacks of the British and native Americans. It was there, on August 19, 1782, that the Soldiers en route to the battle at Blue Licks stopped to eat and rest. 

The Old Stone Tavern in 2018, courtesy of 
Christopher Riley's Flicker account.



The Ruins of the Old Stone Tavern at Ellisville,
courtesy of Google Maps, August 202
3.





[When the act] was passed that moved the county seat of Nicholas County to the farm of James Ellis. Ellis deeded the county the necessary acreage of land, across the road from his home, to build a courthouse and a jail. Later in 1807, James Ellis built his final residence nearby his log tavern. This home was also a tavern that was later a residence of the McClanahan Family. Charles McClanahan, a pioneer who is buried in the cemetery, help move the stones to the site where the Stone Tavern was being built, when he was only 10 years old.

Arieal view of Ellisville, courtesy of Google Maps.
The red dot is the Old Stone Tavern location. And 
according to Mr. Riley, the old courthouse and jail 
used to sit across the road from it. 


James Ellis sold scores of lots to individuals who wanted to live in the new county seat, and the residents named the area Ellisville in his honor. But the county seat was short lived, for in 1816 another act was passed that moved the county seat from Ellisville to Carlisle. The Courthouse and jail were razed and moved there also. Following its demotion from county seat, progress suffered at Ellisville and many of its businesses shut down.


Although the community was no longer the county seat, it still kept its name and persisted for many decades before it lost all its business. Many families continued living there, and soon Ellisville established a cemetery on the McClanahan's farm for the community to lay their loved ones to rest. Today, the cemetery is privately owned and is not visible when driving down US 68.

The abandoned Ellisville Cemetery. Now overgrown.
Photo courtesy of  Riley Mola / Find-A-Grave.





James Ellis's Stone Tavern still stands to this day and the remains of the pioneers of Ellisville are interred in the cemetery just across the road. A few country homes, The Old Stone Tavern, and fields of tobacco are all that's left of the beautiful little town of Ellisville as we drive down US 68."

UPDATE: According to the Nicholas County Tourism Department,, the Stone Tavern is still standing as of today, "but barely."  It's most likely not safe for anyone to enter or visit.

Mr. Riley Mola's description of Ellisville is about the only one you can find online. Just as the town has about all vanished physically, it has also done so historically. There's not much information out there at all. 


This is why the work that historians such as myself and others do is so important. Unless we preserve what little history is left, it will soon be forgotten.


Saturday, October 7, 2023

Carl Newton Mahan: The Youngest Murderer To Ever Stand Trial


I'm not sure why, but this case from 1929 is once again receiving a lot of attention.  Several YouTube videos have been done on the case within the past year. So let us too take a look at the case.


One of the biggest mysteries when it comes to crime is what causes young kids to do bad things? We know that we are all a product of our environment.  But could there also be underlying factors as well?  


This is a true story of a 6 year old boy-turned-killer in Paintsville, Kentucky.


Paintsville is the county seat of Johnson County. It was originally known as Paint Lick Station, then Paint Creek, before becoming Paintsville in 1843.  


Paintsville has given birth to numerous celebrities over the years, including country music star Crystal Gayle, Major League Baseball stars Willie Blair and Johnnie LeMaster, and may more.  But it was also the home of the youngest murderer in American history - Carl Mahan. 

Carl Newton Mahan


Carl Mahan was born on September 22, 1922 there in Johnson County. He was the son of John Mahan and Cora Dixon Mahan.


Cecil Vanhoose was born March 17, 1921 in Johnson County, the son of Albert Jackson Vanhoose and Vera Ann Blair Vanhoose.


These two families were neighbors and friends. And on May 18, 1929, six year old Carl and eight year old Cecil, who had been playmates, were out scouting for scrap metal.  This was just months before the stock market crash of 1929, but according to other historians, the folks of Paintsville were already falling into poverty.  So the boys were out looking for scrap iron in hopes of selling it for a few cents to buy some candy.


Scrap iron was found by the two, but that piece of scrap iron would cause the death of Cecil.  How? Well I'm about to tell you. 


The two boys began arguing over the possession of the scrap iron. The argument lead to a fight. The two battled for some time when Mahan told Vanhoose that he was going to kill him, and started toward home.  When Mahan got home, he climbed upon the back of a chair and got his father's shotgun.  He aimed the gun at Vanhoose and pulled the trigger.  He then returned the shotgun to its place. John Mahan, Carl's Father, stated that Carl told him that he "wouldn't have done it if he had known the gun was loaded."


Cecil Vanhoose, the victim

  Although mortally wounded, Cecil ran toward his home crying "Mamma! Mamma!".  He ran a few yards before he collapsed. Neighbors ran to his assistance, placed him in a car and rushed him to the hospital.  But he breathed his last breath just as they reached the hospital.


When questioned by the authorities, Mahan admitted to the shooting.  He showed the officers how he got the gun. He then showed them how he opened the door and fired the gun at Cecil.  He allegedly told the officers that he intended to kill Cecil and would do the same thing again.

 Young Cecil Vanhoose was buried in the Mayo Cemetery in Paintsville, KY. And Mahan was arraigned for his murder and was scheduled to stand trial on May 23, 1929. However the judicial system in Johnson County found itself with a case for which there had been no precedent.   The prosecutor stated that there was nothing in Kentucky law to guide him in prosecuting a child under 10 in serious matters. The law suggested that a child under that age could not be "held to account." So it was up to the jury to decide what to do.



The Gravesite of Cecil Vanhoose - Mayo Cemetery, Paintsville, KY.


The defense asked for a jury trial because they were afraid that the judge would sentence Carl to reform school.  The request was granted.  However the jury selection set off an altercation between Sheriff Harry Adams and Judge John W. Butcher, and the Sheriff was fined $3.00 (the equivalent of $53.53 in today's money.) The Judge claimed that the Sheriff was not bringing in veniremen and the Sheriff reported that he was not being furnished with the venire lists.  The County Jailer ended up becoming a peacemaker in the matter.


The selected jury consisted of: William Puckett, farmer; Lum Green, farmer; Samuel Cantrell, storekeeper; Sanford Stapleton, teamster; Tina Hazelett, miner; Frank Brown, farmer; Ray Turner, farmer; Bascom Stanley, farmer; Isaac Hamilton, farmer; James Gibbs, miner; Tom Hazelett, teamster, and Sam Brown, miner. 


Carl Mahan went on trial laughing and talking with his friends and did not realize that he was being tried on a serious charge.   


During the trial Carl told his side of the story of the shooting. The two had been seeking scrap metal to sell.  Carl found the "prize piece" of scrap metal of the hunt, and Cecil tried to take it away from him. Cecil, being older and bigger succeeded in taking the scrap metal from Carl.  Carl  then went into his house, stood up on a chair, got his fathers shotgun off the wall, opened the door, pulled the trigger. The charge struck Cecil, and he died later.

The Mahan Family Home in Paintsville, KY


Witnesses for the prosecution included Manuel Fitzpatrick, Mrs. Manuel Fitzpatrick, and Albert Vanhoose, father of the slain boy.    Vanhoose testified that he was not at home and knew nothing of the shooting until later. He was not cross examined.


Mrs. Fitzpatrick testified that she heard the quarreling from her back door. She stated that she heard Carl Mahan tell Cecil Vanhoose that if he did not give up the piece of scrap iron that he would kill him.  She stated that Vanhoose continued to hold on to  the scrap iron and Carl again cried out that he would get a gun and kill him.  She stated that  she thought it was just a childish quarrel and never paid anymore attention to the boys, until she heard a gunshot about five minutes later.  She went on to state that Cecil, though shot, was running from the yard  and she overtook him and helped put him into an automobile. He was taken to the hospital where he died on the examining table. 


Mr. Fitzpatrick testified that he was at home at the time but not in the rear of the house so he did not hear any of the argument between the two boys. 


The jury deliberated just thirty minutes before rendering a verdict of guilty of the charge of manslaughter. Judge John W. Butcher sentenced six year old Carl to 15 years in the Glendale, Kentucky reform school. 
Judge John W. Butcher


Defense Attorney John Wheeler immediately announced that he would file a motion for a new trial. Judge Butcher took the motion under advisement. 


Just as promised, Attorney Wheeler filed the motion for a new trial under the charges that 

*the court permitted incompetent evidence to be introduced,

*refused to allow the defense to introduce certain evidence,

*that as the defendant is under the age of seven the court had no jurisdiction,

*that the jury's verdict was not supported by competent evidence,

*that since the child was charged with murder and not charged with delinquency, the court had no jurisdiction in the case except to transfer it to the Johnson County Circuit Court for trail, and lastly,

*the court improperly instructed the jury. The jury received only meager instructions from Judge Butcher. He said, in part: "I can see only two things in this case - acquittal or conviction. If you gentleman believe that this boy did not know it was  wrong to take the life of another, or  that he did not know what he was doing at the time of the killing, you must bring in a verdict of not guilty.  But if you believe that he knew it was wrong to kill and knew what he was doing, you must bring a verdict of guilty."


Judge Butcher  stated that he would not act upon the motion for a new trial until Judge Bailey has passed on the prohibition writ.


Overruling of the motions by County Judge John W. Butcher, who presided at the jury trial that found Carl guilty automatically sent the prohibition writ  before District Judge J.F. Bailey of Lexington.


In addition to filing for a new trial, the Counsel for Mahan requested a writ to prohibit him from being sent to reform school.  Judge  J.F. Bailey issued the writ. 

Judge J.F. Bailey


Judge Bailey held that Judge Butcher exceeded his authority when he pronounced sentence after a jury had found the boy guilty of manslaughter. "There is no doubt he exceeded his authority", said Bailey. He held that Judge Butcher had no jurisdiction to give a final decision on anyone charged with murder.


Judge Bailey went on to say that there was no law in Kentucky under which a child under 10 years' might be confined to a reform school.


During the proceedings Carl sat with his parents and Mrs. Harry Neugel, social worker of Cincinnati.  Carl amused himself by looking at the comic section of newspapers, chewing gum, and playing quietly. He paid no attention to what was going on.


Governor Flem Sampson refused to intervene in the case, stating "I feel sure there will be no miscarriage of justice, that the courts will handle the case properly."


Mrs. Emma Hunt, director of the Kentucky Children's Bureau, took the first steps toward deciding young Carl's future.


Mrs. Hunt called a conference of defense and prosecution counsel in the recent trials. She said she had not decided what would be done by the bureau to which Carl was paroled by County Judge John W. Butcher after he had been declared delinquent.


After reviewing the views of those invited to the conference she stated that she will make her recommendations to the bureau's governing board the following week.


Psychologists ran tests on Carl and revealed that Carl had no criminal tendencies and that he didn't realize the wrong he had committed. 


On June 26, 1929, Kentucky Attorney General J.W. Cammack, to whom the authorities had left the final decision on an appeal, announced that his department had completed a study of the case records. And it was understood that he would take no action.


That left young Carl in the custody of his parents, protected from imprisonment by a writ of prohibition issued by Judge J.F. Bailey. One month and three days after the original trial, the case was done.

Six Year Old Carl Mahan with his family: L-R
Cora Mahan, Mother, John Mahan, Father, and Grandmother Roxie Tackett


Carl and his family would move to Louisville, KY at some point after the trial.  It was there in April 28, 1958 at the age of 35, Carl Mahan would take his own life.  


In a closing note, as I was researching this case, I found both of these boys - Carl Mahan and Cecil Vanhoose, in my ancestral tree. In fact, young Cecil was somewhat closely related to me.

Saturday, September 30, 2023

"I Love You But I'm Going To Kill You"

 When it comes to subjects for blogs, I really have no method. I keep a list of subjects that I would like to eventually cover, but I really have no method of choosing which ones to cover and when.


But this blog is an exception to that.  I was working on another blog when I ran across this crime story.  And my gut feeling was that I needed to stop working on the other blog and instead do this one. It was as if this story must be told and told now.   I listened to my "gut" and that is what I did.


So here is "I Love You But I'm Going To Kill You."


 Jack Claude Cobern was born June 2, 1926, in Ashland, KY, a son of the late William Vernal Cobern and Ethel Schattinger Cobern.


Not much is known about Jack's life other than he served in the United States Marines during World War II, and he served for nine years with the Kentucky State Police. For a few years of that time, he was stationed with the Kentucky State Police Post 8 here in my hometown of Morehead, KY. He resigned after being transferred from Morehead to London, KY.  He would later become the owner of the Boonesboro Boat Club Restaurant at Boonesborough, KY.


Despite his honorable service with the Marines and the Kentucky State Police, Jack will most likely be remembered for the events of August 21, 1963.


The family babysitter, Donna McIntosh, told authorities that on the evening of Wednesday, August 21, 1963, Jack's wife, Anna Jean Morguson Cobern, came home from working her shift at the Dixie Cup Plant on Industry Road in Lexington, Ky. Jack, who had been drinking, was waiting for her at their home on Bryan Avenue in Lexington.

Jean Cobern
1930-1963
photo courtesy of FamilySearch / Jackie Cobern


Jack instructed McIntosh to go upstairs and get the baby. McIntosh got the baby and returned. It was then   McIntosh stated that she heard Cobern tell Jean "I love you but I'm going to kill you."  And Jack then shot Jean with a .38 caliber pistol while they both were sitting at the dining room table. The bullet struck Jean in the left chest, below the breast.  The bullet lodged at the back of her spine.


McIntosh stated that she witnessed the shooting from the living room.


After being shot, Mrs. Cobern arose from the table and ran from the house into the front yard yelling "I'm dying! I'm dying!"


  McIntosh stated that Jack followed her outside and waited with her until the city police arrived. Police stated that when they arrived, Jack was holding her in his arms in the driveway.  Blood was evident on his shirt, trousers, and tie where he had attempted to aid her.


Jean told police that her husband had shot her.


Jack admitted to shooting her but would not make a formal statement as to the reason. Instead, he told Patrolman D.F. Sallee "This is the worst thing I've ever done. What is it that makes a man shoot his wife?"  


Both of the Cobern's children were in the home when the shooting occurred. The youngest, which was approximately a year old, was with Miss McIntosh. The seven-year-old was upstairs when the shooting occurred. 


Jean was taken to Good Samaritan Hospital where she underwent surgery. She died about three hours later.  She was taken to the Edgington Funeral Home in Winchester. She is buried the Winchester Cemetery. 

Jean Cobern Gravesite


Initially Jack was charged with malicious shooting and wounding with the intent to kill. However, when Jean passed away from her injuries, a charge of murder was added. He was held in the Fayette County jail in lieu of a $5,000.00 bond.  The examining trial was set for Thursday, August 22, 1963, in Quarterly Court at Lexington.


The Examining Trial

During the examining hearing Jack was held to the Grand Jury on a charge of murder and bond was set at $10,000.00


Testimony about Jean's statement was given by Police Lieutenant A.M. Carter. Carter stated that he had spoken to Jean in the emergency room shortly after the shooting.  Jean told Carter over and over that her husband shot her and that she was going to die and didn't want to die. But she never said anything about the circumstances that may have lead up to the shooting.


I'm not sure if this is still the case or not, but at the time, under criminal law a statement by a victim who realizes they are going to die is admissible in the prosecution of a homicide.


Coroner Chester Hager said that shortly after Cobern was informed of Jean's death Jack said that he had been a former state police sergeant, had carried a gun since he was 17, and had been taught to kill.  Hager stated that Jack said he "didn't mean to kill her.", and that the shooting was in sudden heat and passion.


Mrs. Phyllis White, a co-worker of Jean's, stated that she arrived at the Cobern residence moments before the shooting to visit Jean. She stated that she saw Jack coming down the stairway inside the house and that he said to Jean "you're still legally my wife", and he was carrying a pistol.  


White stated that she left the house immediately although Jean called to her to come back.  White stated that she heard the shot as she drove away.


Patrolman Donald Sallee, who had been the first on the scene, said that Jack admitted the shooting and turned over a .38 caliber pistol containing four live shells and one spent shell.


The Indictment and Trial


On Monday, September 23, 1963, Jack was indicted for the murder of his wife Jean.  The trial was scheduled for February 3, 1964, but was then reassigned to the June 1964 term of the court.


In May 1964 and prior to his trial, Jack was fined $150.00 and costs on a drunk driving charge, amended to driving contrary to law.


On June 29, 1964, Jack pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in Circuit Court and was sentenced to ten years in the penitentiary.


Sometime after the trial and sentencing, Jack remarried. He married Laura Belle Gribbins Cobern.  He passed away on January 25, 1989, and is buried in Marion County, KY.


As a result of this crime, two children grew up without their mother or father. That is the sad reality of this case.



Saturday, September 23, 2023

GHOSTS CAUSE TERROR!!

 GHOSTS

 Cause Terror In Lewis County Oil Camp

------

They Knock On The Roofs And Terrify Sleepers By Walking Over Beds

------

Mr. Gottlilsch Moves Out

-----

Old Resident's Story of How He Met Three Headless Women At Midnight

------

Site Of Indian Massacre



The Vanceburg Sun says: For some days past excitement has prevailed at the Kinniconick Oil Camp, not saying that excitement is any unusual state of affairs since the oil boom struck Straight Fork some months ago. But a new feature somewhat more novel and Interesting to the nonresidents of the camp is now disclosed.


We shall attempt to describe, if though vaguely and imperfectly, the maneuvers of what, for want of a more suitable name, must be called a ghost, and as writers of ghost stories have, it seems, acquired quite a reputation from the reckless manner in which they seem to deal with truth, we shall endeavor to give accurate details, which may be verified by any of the members of the said company, so to begin.


 The members of the company mentioned above occupied a house owned and occupied a few years ago by E.W. Bryant, who recently moved to Olive Hill. 


Mr. Bryant and his family, with but little ado moved suddenly from the building which was then comparatively new into an old log house on the same place.


 Shrewd enough he was in not allowing the fact that the building was haunted to become public and, so fortunately for him, disposed of it before the circumstances became generally known.


About a week ago the specter made Its initial visit to the present occupants of the building while a protracted meeting was being held in the neighborhood.


 One just after dusk, several churchgoers were called in to bear the peculiar rapping it persisted In making, which must have been similar to rapple familiar to the soldier. The noise at that time was made on the roof of the building at different points and at various intervals, and some of the boys were of the opinion that It was a sport of the neighborhood amusing himself at their expense and a search of the premises was made. Finally, forbearance ceasing to be a virtue, a repeating rifle was brought out with the remark, "I just dare you to do that again," but the word dare seemed only a signal for a recommencement of the proceedings instanter. The owner of the rifle was afterward seen very carefully removing evidence of its sudden immersion in a mud puddle, and some, were of the opinion that a Bible might prove more defensive in such an emergency than a repeating rife.


To relieve the monotony of rappings frequent falling as of some heavy weight on the second story floor would be accompanied by groanings which might be expressive of the feelings of the lost in the lower regions of eternal darkness, and now, as this nocturnal visitor which had been ordering dreams for the crew in serial form during a succession of nights, concluded that its presence had not been sufficiently manifested, made an effort the result of which was gratifying to such an extent that it was made final. 


Messrs. Gottllsch and Frank Rowland, occupying the same room, seemed to be commanding the especial attention of this ghost, and on this last visit Mr. Gottlisch was awakened as by some thing or person walking over him. and at almost the same moment Frank Rowland jumped from his bed in another part of the room with a terrifying yell that "there it was" and trying to catch the thing which he says he plainly saw, and which had unmistakable weight, but no material body was there to meet his clutches. 


Little wonder it is that when the other occupants brought in a light on these subjects they found them with every individual hair on their heads standing on tiptoe, and every color in their faces that had no business there, and an endless procession of lumps still chasing each other in hot haste up their throats. 


Mr. Upton. one of the preachers, spent the night with them on one occasion, and although he does not testify to the apparition, confirms report that there is something extraordinary about the case, "as sure God," and explained further that "it was not appointed for man to understand the workings of the spirit." 


On two different occasions a ghost conducted Frank Rowland past the haunted house when he was returning from church up to the head of Cherry Camp when each time Wad Morgan's timely appearance caused the ghost to release Mr. Rowland and influence him to return, then favor Mr. Morgan with its attention.


 lr is reported by the older inhabitants that a tradition has been handed down that many years ago an Indian massacre was committed in this vicinity, and while it is not known   exactly where the outrage was committed, it is thought probable that it occurred on the site of the present haunted building.


In conclusion, we will mention that James Bryant, an old resident of this place, a few years ago met, a short distance from this ghostly rendezvous, three headless women dressed in white sauntering along the road about midnight, and also that E. W. Bryant, one-night last winter, while riding near the same place saw a monstrous frog following him along the road. From his description the creature resembled an enormous frog being subject to the X-ray test, it being translucent with luminous eyes, which were constantly blinking at him. 


The affair Is a neighborhood topic and can be substantiated by many reputable persons in the community and will be held in dread remembrance by the gentleman whose headquarters have been in the building. Mr. Gottlisch returned to his home in the city this week, where ghosts and rumors of ghosts will not mar the even tenor of his everyday life.


Published in the Courier-Journal, Louisville, KY, December 21, 1902.


Tuesday, September 19, 2023

Rev. John William McGarvey Part Two: The Conclusion

 

JOHN WILLIAM McGARVEY AS PROFESSOR AND PRESIDENT.  

 (published in The College of The Bible Quarterly Bulletin, November 1911)



In 1865 John William McGarvey was elected Professor of Sacred History in what was then the College of the Bible of Kentucky University. Upon the organization of the College of the Bible as a separate institution in 1875 he took the same position in it which he had held in the former institution, In 1895, upon the resignation of President Robert Graham, Prof. McGarvey was chosen President of the. College of the Bible, which position he held continuously until the day of his death, October 6, 1911.



His accession to the presi
dency did not interrupt his work as a professor. He continued to teach until up to within less than a year of his death. Owing to the increasing infirmities of age, his work as a teacher and executive was lightened very much by the younger members of the faculty within the last years of his life. At the beginning of the session of 1910 he voluntarily relinquished his two classes in secred history to Prof. H. L. Calhoun, continuing to  teach only one class, viz., the class in Old Testament Prophecy; this class also he gave up at the end of the first semester of 1910. The executive duties which had been discharged by him until the beginning of the session of 1910 were gradually transferred almost wholly to the dean of the faculty of the College of the Bible so that for the last year of his life he retained only a very general oversight of the work of the college. He realized fully that his work in the college must be entrusted to other hands at some time and with that rare good sense and practical wisdom which were so characteristic of the man, he made the transfer while he was yet living so that when the day of his death came his departure caused not the slightest change in the general work of the college. He had so perfectly set his house in order that his passing from the work in the college was accomplished without a jar to the working of the machinery of the school. The general condition of the College of the Bible was never better than it is this year, and its prospects for the future are full of promise. While the members of the faculty will sadly miss the wise counsel and fatherly advice of our departed president, they are glad to believe that, in harmony with the most earnest wishes and prayers of our chief, the school will continue to grow in efficiency and usefulness with even greater rapidity than it has done in the past.



As a teacher Prof. McGarvey was characterized by the profundity and clearness of his thinking. He had the happy faculty possessed by all truly great men of stating great truths in simple and lucid language. He impressed his pupils always with the thought that he sought only the truth and that he and they must follow that at all hazards. He was never boisterous—nor domineering—neither was he hesitant, nor compromising. Calm and self-possessed at all times, he pursued without fear or favor the line of his investigation, rejoicing always at every acquisition of new truth. It is doubtful if any man ever lived who had a better knowledge of the English Bible than he. As an executive he was always prompt, orderly and efficient. No important matter was ever neglected. He always found time for every detail, and yet he never seemed to be hurried nor worried over the multiplicity of his duties. He leaves behind him a blessed memory and an example which will inspire us all to heroic endeavor.

JOHN W. McGARVEY AS A CHURCH MEMBER.

Henry J. LUNGER.


Men and women who have been members of Chestnut Street Christian Church are in all countries and serving the Master in many high places. This is in a measure true of all churches with an equal age and membership, but true of it to a remarkable degree. Some others of those in its membership, who walked with God and whose influence for good was far felt, have gone to their great reward, and their memory is that church's greatest treasure. Greatest   among them, most honored, most beloved, and most lamented, is our Brother  McGarvey, whose precious fellowship we miss because God took him to the fellowship of the just made perfect.


Brother McGarvey constantly emphasized the importance of the work of the preacher and the teacher, the elders and the deacons, but even more the importance of being a church member. For him there was no churchless Christianity. He urged all to attend church and become a member of the church; but merely “belonging to the church” was not enough; there must be something more, and what that something is he illustrated with his life. In speaking to the new students who came to the College of the Bible this year, he urged them to become members of churches in Lexington at once, and said that in choosing the church which they would make their home they should choose the one where they could get the most good and where they could give the most aid and consider the latter as of the more importance. This is the rule which he followed and the joy and help he received from the worship, and the interests in the church of which he was a member and the success of his efforts in its behalf show the wisdom of the plan.



To his brethren in the church he was cordial and loving; inquiring about their welfare, giving encouragement and advice, lending aid, and in every way strengthening the bonds of friendship and fraternity.

 

When there was work to do he was glad to bear more than his share of the burden. He gave liberally of his means to the support of the church, and that without being urged to do so; on the contrary, he would keep asking about the financial conditions of the church and offering to do more if there was need, No call for preaching or other good work came unheeded by him.


 As to his church attendance, his regularity and punctuality were remarkable. There had to be serious hindrances indeed to keep him from the meetings. And on entering the church he went immediately to his place and for him the worship began then. Usually he would take his hymn book and read a hymn and would continue in reading and meditation until after the regular services began. Then he would enter heartily into the exercises of the hour. He sang little, but enjoyed the songs, especially if they were hymns of real merit.



An eloquent listener is a great aid to the preacher, and in this Brother McGarvey excelled. His hearing was so poor that in large assemblies, or anywhere that he did not have his. device with him, he could not hear the speaker at all. “Then,” said he to me once, “all I get is the gestures, and they are usually more amusing than edifying.” But in his home church he could

follow at least the main subjects of the sermon, while his face showed his interest and his thoughtfulness. After I began preaching at Chestnut Street, I soon learned how much his presence helped me, and when he was absent I missed his keen appreciation, his kindly criticism, his warm handshake, and his genial smile. His attitude throughout the service was very devotional—God was very near, very dear, very real.



To him the Lord’s Supper was very important and he was earnest in trying to retain its primitive simplicity and orderliness. It was in this connection that one of his fine  characteristics showed itself most distinctly. I remember asking him once whether he were an officer of the Chestnut Street Church, and he answered, with that twinkle in his eye that showed that he appreciated the humor of the answer, “No, not an officer, just a high private.”  And so, when it came to the Lord’s Supper, though he generally conducted the ordinance, he never went to the table until by word or gesture he was invited to do so by one of the officers.


His talks at the beginning of the Lord’s Supper were edifying, spiritual, and withal practical; they were filled with teaching, exhortation, and encouragement, and were of such a devotional character as to prepare the heart for the ordinance itself.


But, though he was so loved and admired by all, though he did so much for and in the church, and though he was so highly honored by the brotherhood and the world, these things did not spoil him.  So in the church he was only a member among members, but such a member! So loving, so humble, so devout, so faithful, so sincere.


In his going the officers of the church have lost a wise counsellor and helper; the members have lost a beloved brother and leader; and the church has lost from its membership one of the few of his generation who had so good a right to be called great, and the beauty of whose life, the greatness of whose soul, and the sweetness of whose fellowship endeared him to all. But there remains a memory which will always be for it a priceless possession.


PRESIDENT McGARVEY AS AUTHOR.

B. C. DEWEESE.


For about sixty years he wrote for the press as editor of “The Apostolic Times,” weekly Sunday school lessons, geographical notes for S. S, Annuals, and for eighteen years he conducted the department of Biblical Criticism in the Christian Standard. Everything written in these publications was carefully prepared and always with the aim to set forth Scripture teaching on the subjects considered.


As an author of books he wrote to meet popular needs and specialized also in the field of Biblical Criticism. His popular works were Lands of the Bible, Commentaries on Matthew and Mark and Acts. The second named was the first of a series in the New Testament planned by the Disciples of Christ, but never completed. His book on Acts was published in 1864, when he was but thirty-four. The demand for it was immediate, and it was of value to young preachers and intelligent church workers. Reading it also won many souls to Christ. After twenty-nine years it was re-written. In both forms it was re-printed frequently. Forty-eight years is a long life of usefulness in our time for a commentary. James Hastings, the great encyclopedia maker, in a review of the re-written edition said he would keep it on his study-table for constant reference.



“Lands of the Bible" was the most popular of his books. More than eighteen thousand copies have been sold and it is still in demand. It has been widely used as a text-book for ministerial students. President John A.  Broadus, a most competent judge of books in the field, wrote to me: “Your Professor McGarvey has written the best single volume in print on Palestine.”


President McGarvey’s latest, most carefully considered, and strongest work has been done on the subject of Biblical criticism. His volume of essays and notes reprinted from what he wrote for the Christian Standard give good illustration of his popular method in dealing with the subject. His “Jesus and Jonah” he wrote to refute the view, common to advanced critics, that Jesus was not at all an authority on the authorship and reliability of the Old Testament. This opinion aroused his.indignation.and his spirit rose to oppose and expose its error. “The Authorship of Deuteronomy” received more of his thoughtful study by far than did any other work by his hand. For forty years he had studied the question in the writings of the advanced higher critics. He knew their. views better than most of the leading writers of that school did. He studied the Bible to see if these claims were true. Satisfying himself that they were false, he chose to refute them by testing them as applied by these critics to the authorship of Deuteronomy. This effort he considered his best work and gave it his best mental effort. Space limits prevent fuller notice and exclude the mention of other titles.



Every book written by him was written to explain or defend the Bible. He always sought the ablest writers against it for his attack. His knowledge of the facts, their logical arrangement, and his exceptional clearness in presenting them in the people’s vocabulary made him an able controversialist. A long life, fidelity to his convictions, hard study, service of the church, and a reverence and love for God’s' Word made him a great power and a choice spirit.

FROM THE RECORDS OF THE FACULTY.


The faculty of the College of the Bible feel the death of their venerable and beloved President, John W. McGarvey, as a most painful personal bereavement, and account it as an immeasurable and irreparable loss to our College.

In all his official and personal relations with us he was ever so considerate, sympathetic, and generous as to win not only our confidence and esteem, but also our warm and abiding affection. We shall sorely miss his genial presence, wise counsel, and inspiring leadership.


For nearly half a century he gave himself in unstinted devotion to the founding and fostering of the College of the Bible, and to his heroic sacrifice and efficient service is due a large measure of its present greatness and prosperity. The ideal which he ever cherished for this beloved institution, and to the realization of which he consecrated all his power, was that it might become the best and greatest institution in the world for preparation of the ministry of the Word of God.

With the bereaved family and with all the relatives and friends we deeply sympathize in the loss sustained by the departure of this great and good man.


PRESIDENT J. W. McGARVEY AS A MAN.
by S. M. JEFFERSON.

Perhaps President McGarvey was most widely known as a defender of the faith, because in most of his published writings he appeared always and only as one contending earnestly for the faith once for all delivered to the saints. For this work he was well prepared, and he devoted himself to its accomplishment with dauntless courage and with conspicuous ‘success. For his zeal and victories in this holy warfare he is widely known and highly honored by multitudes of believers who with him love the precious Word of God.


But great as he was as the champion of the truth, he was greaterd still as its embodiment and the living exemplification of its blessedness and beauty in his own character and conduct. He realized that not warfare but work is the ultimate condition of all true progress and prosperity, and that having won the right and room to live the real worth of the victory is measured by the life achieved in peace. And so he grew to his superior greatness by daily nourishing his soul with the word of life, by fellowship with Jesus Christ, and by communion with God and with the Holy Spirit. Those who knew him intimately recognized and rejoiced in this spiritual greatness most of all. His family, his college faculty, and his personal friends found in him in abundance “the fruit of the Spirit, love, joy, peace, long suffering. kindness, goodness, faithfulness, meekness, self-control.”

Not as a polemic or controversialist, but as an eminent and inspiring ex- ample of Christian manhood in its strength and beauty will his most intimate friends revere his memory and mourn his loss




PRESIDENT J. W. McGARVEY AS A STUDENT.

William Francis Smith

A cold has kept ex-President C. L. Loos from furnishing us an article on this topic. He hopes to do so later. President McGarvey has himself published statements on his methods of study, hoping in this way to aid the mistaken and the untaught. He considered that the results from such articles were meagre. Hence, for years he has believed that the personal oversight of trained leaders is essential to the development of local teachers and students.


His primary aim as a Biblical student was the discovery of the writer's thought, his whole thought, and his thought as he himself had modified it. He was too earnest to be content with culling. With rare powers of self-repression he submerged his own thoughts and desires in his search for the meaning of scripture. These simple principles, though often stated and praised, have not prevailed extensively in the Sunday school or the pulpit. This he realized and deplored. A prominent attorney, who studied. the Old Testament for one year under Prof. McGarvey, says that the method of handling the matter has been worth more to him than any other undergraduate work.


Prof. McGarvey was largely self-taught. His success commends his methods. His firmness in maintaining his views was due to the fact that they were as he believed, visibly set forth in the Bible.


THE FUTURE OF THE COLLEGE OF THE BIBLE
by Hall Laurie Calhoun, Dean of College of The Bible

The death of President McGarvey. whose presence in the College of the Bible since its founding has been a source of so much influence and power in shaping the policy and conduct of the school, naturally raises the question in the minds of many of its friends—What about the future of the College? This question on their part is the outgrowth of genuine interest in the welfare and prosperity of the College. To the present faculty and student body and to the friends of the school who reside in Lexington the question does not appeal with so much force as to the friends of the school who are further away and per consequence who are less well acquainted with the condition of affairs in the school. But to one and all it may be said with absolute assurance that the future of the College of the Bible is bright with splendid prospects. It is now in a very prosperous year—with a full faculty, a large student body, and every department moving with the regularity of clock work. Thanks in large part to the wise forethought of President McGarvey, all arrangements had been made for the inevitable event of his passing from our midst and so perfectly had these plans heen set in operation that his death did not occasion the slightest change in any of the work of the school. The executive and educative details had all been planned so as to ge on without his active participation for more than a year previous to his death. Although we miss him more than words can tell, and though the man is gone, his work moves on with splendid success. It is the ardent hope of those who are left that the aim which our departed and highly honored President so often set before us shall be realized. viz., that the College of the Bible shall become the greatest institution for Biblical training in the world.  Believing that the school already justly occupies this position, in the estimation of the people, it is the fixed purpose of its faculty and friends that it shall at no very distant day be so recognized throughout the world.  To the accomplishment of this worthy aim we pledge our lives and our labor.

Forgotten Kentucky: The Day a Fighter Plane Chased a UFO Over Fort Knox

  Courtesy of The Morehead Minute Newsletter: By Joe Clark For The Morehead Minute Long before The X-Files , before Project Blue Book becam...