Revenge on Marrowbone Creek:
By Joe Clark
On the evening of October 30, 1966, a quiet stretch of Marrowbone Creek in Pike County, Kentucky, became the scene of one of eastern Kentucky's most heartbreaking family murders.
Nine-year-old James Edward Bartley would never make it home.
The person accused of taking his life was the one person who was supposed to protect him most—his own father.
A Ride That Never Ended
Late Sunday afternoon, Donald B. Bartley picked up his young son James.
The child had been living with his mother following his parents' divorce earlier that year. According to testimony presented later at trial, custody arrangements allowed Donald visitation with James during the weekend before returning him to his mother.
Instead of returning home, father and son drove toward Lookout School on Marrowbone Creek.
Exactly what happened there has never been known with complete certainty.
What is known is that sometime that evening, James was shot multiple times in the chest with a .22 caliber weapon.
Donald Bartley also suffered a gunshot wound to his side.
No murder weapon was ever recovered.
The Story About the Hunters
Around 3:45 p.m. Donald Bartley drove into a service station near the mouth of Marrowbone Creek with his son lying beside him.
James was already dead.
Bartley told attendants—and later investigators—that he and his son had been parked near Lookout School when two strange men dressed as hunters approached.
According to Bartley, the men demanded money.
When he refused, they allegedly opened fire before fleeing into the woods.
It sounded like the plot of a crime novel.
Investigators, however, immediately noticed problems.
There were no witnesses.
There were no bullet holes or damage to the outside of the automobile that would support shots being fired from outside the vehicle.
The physical evidence simply did not fit Bartley's story.
A Different Theory
As detectives dug deeper, another picture emerged.
Donald and his wife had divorced only months earlier.
Court records showed that Jean Bartley had been awarded custody of James, while Donald was granted visitation.
Witnesses testified that Donald desperately wanted his family back.
Jean did not.
She had moved away after the divorce before eventually returning to Pike County.
According to her testimony, Donald repeatedly threatened that if he could not have the family together again, no one would.
One statement reportedly haunted the courtroom.
Jean testified Donald had warned:
"If I can't have one, there'll be another one—meaning the one I lost."
She also described another threat in which he allegedly said he would drive an automobile into a river and kill the entire family.
Those statements would become central to the Commonwealth's case.
The Arrest
Because Donald remained hospitalized after surgery for his gunshot wound, officers initially delayed filing charges.
Once his condition improved, Pike County Sheriff Perry Justice formally charged him with murder.
Even while under indictment, legal troubles continued.
After being released from the hospital under bond, Donald was arrested again after his former wife sought a peace bond, alleging he had threatened her following the killing.
The court ordered him jailed under the peace bond while awaiting trial.
The Defense
Donald Bartley pleaded:
- Not Guilty
- Not Guilty by Reason of Temporary Insanity
Doctors from Eastern State Hospital later testified that Bartley suffered from schizophrenia, described at the time as a "split personality."
According to their testimony, he experienced periods during which he lost contact with reality and could not distinguish truth from falsehood.
The defense attempted to convince jurors that Bartley's mental illness prevented him from understanding his actions.
Prosecutors disagreed.
They argued that the murder had been planned.
The Commonwealth maintained Donald killed James to punish his former wife for divorcing him and refusing reconciliation.
The Jury Decides
The case went to the Pike County jury in late 1966.
After hearing testimony from doctors, law enforcement officers, forensic experts, and Jean Bartley herself, the case was submitted for deliberation.
The jury took only ten minutes.
Donald Bartley was found guilty of murdering his nine-year-old son.
He was sentenced to life imprisonment.
James Bartley
Newspaper accounts reveal little about James beyond the circumstances of his death.
He was only nine years old.
He had been spending the weekend with his father.
Within hours, he was gone.
His funeral was held at the home of his grandfather, with burial in the family cemetery on Marrowbone Creek.
Like so many child victims whose stories become overshadowed by courtroom proceedings, James' life was reduced in newspaper headlines to evidence, testimony, and verdicts.
Donald Bartley's Final Years
Donald Bartley served his sentence in the Kentucky prison system.
He died in Lexington, Kentucky, in 1976, approximately ten years after the murder.
He was only in his early forties.
The headlines stopped.
The court files were closed.
But for the Bartley family, October 30, 1966, undoubtedly remained a day that changed everything forever.
A Case That Still Resonates
Today, family annihilations and child homicides often receive national media attention. In 1966, however, cases like this were largely covered by local newspapers and wire services before fading from public memory.
The Bartley case remains a tragic reminder that domestic violence and family-related homicides are not modern phenomena. They have been part of Kentucky's history for generations.
Behind every headline was a child with a future that never came to be.
James Edward Bartley was one of them.
